Thursday 24 March 2016

Call It ‘Shangri-La’ If You Want, Harker…

…we still don’t want them in the UK:
Chances are, your image of a jungle dweller ranges from the savages and headshrinkers of the old Tarzan-era movies to – if you’re more 21st-century – the isolated peoples of the rainforest, living simple yet dignified lives. In either case, are they the kind of people you’d welcome as neighbours, and believe could fully integrate into modern Britain?
For several years now, the series of Calais refugee camps originally set up in 2002 have been referred to as “the Jungle”. The camp was christened by the migrants themselves, in ironic reference to the squalid conditions.
Hey. It’s their camp. If they want to call it that, who are we to complain? That’d probably be racist, or something…
But a decade on, and as the migrant crisis throughout Europe has escalated, it’s clear this term is becoming increasingly problematic.
Oh? Oh, it’s the name that’s problematic, is it? Not the existence of it, or the behaviour of the inmates?

Good to see the ‘Guardian’ focusing on the real issues, as always…
What started out as a simple in-joke among a small group of people has taken on a completely different meaning when taken up by the international media in the context of daily scare stories about people crossing borders. “War of the Jungle” and “Jungle warfare” were just two of the headlines splashed across tabloid front pages last week, as French authorities clashed with refugeesas they moved in to demolish their homes.
The imagery the headlines evoke is of primitive, uncontrolled brutes – of the barbarians at the gates, as they try to gain entry to the UK. Who could possibly want these kind of people tarnishing our green and pleasant land?
It seems the imagery does indeed, for once, match the reality. No wonder you are so upset!
It’s not just the rightwing tabloids that use the term: all parts of the media have adopted it – including the Independent, the BBC and the Guardian (although last week the Guardian issued new guidance to limit its usage, and ensure it always appears in quotation marks).
Yes, it’s most important that the correct language is used. Those quotation marks are vital!
Whether or not you believe the residents of the Calais refugee camp should be allowed into Britain, anyone who thinks these people are fully human, with hopes and aspirations like the rest of us, and lives just as valuable, should cease using language that denies them this humanity.
So to confirm their humanity, we must steadfastly refuse them the right to name their own camp?

For their own good?

I don’t think you’ve really thought this through…

4 comments:

Antisthenes said...

When we lived in caves and were hunter gatherers we were a very savage brutal lot inter tribal warfare was rife with up to 60% of the male population being decimated because of it. Have we moved on from there? I think not the instinct that caused serious conflict and makes us do harm to one another is still there. We see it in the many conflicts now and since that we are just as nasty as ever. So it is no surprise that crime is escalating and harm is being done by immigrants exacerbated by the recent massive rise in numbers. Basic human nature is kicking in they want space and resources to survive and procreate and most will do anything to achieve it.

None of us would do anything different if in the same situation except maybe our consciences are better developed and our fear of retribution is more acute. So perhaps we would be more restrained and civilised. However many of these immigrants come from cultures and environments that neither is much of a deterrent to them behaving badly. So by inviting them in has opened up a whole new can of worms that will not be easily dealt with if at all.

DJ said...

Basic premise fail: I'm thinking most people would rather live next to an Amazonian tribesman than a you-know-who. After all, believing that God can appear to you in the form of a Jaguar is weird but it sure beats believing He wants you to behead people.

Anonymous said...

"A visit to the jungle" is how I describe my occasional trip into the nearest large town.

JuliaM said...

"... the instinct that caused serious conflict and makes us do harm to one another is still there."

Precisely! We need to keep reinventing civilization, or we'll surely lose it.

"After all, believing that God can appear to you in the form of a Jaguar is weird but it sure beats believing He wants you to behead people."

Plus their artwork is much better.

""A visit to the jungle" is how I describe my occasional trip into the nearest large town."

I DON'T visit for that reason!