Tuesday 1 December 2009

”Well, we're safe for now. Thank goodness we're in a bowling alley.”

It's a peril that only a crack team of health and safety experts could have uncovered.

After two years and £250,000, they found that ten-pin bowling alleys up and down the country could be a 'very dangerous' environment for families.
Really? How, exactly?

Is this the danger of getting your fingers caught in the holes and breaking a nail?

Not exactly:
The bizarre Health and Safety Executive report found that members of the public would be at risk if they walked along the 60-foot lanes to knock over pins by hand.
And who would do that?
Its authors even considered ordering every bowling alley to put barriers across lanes. But they were forced to admit defeat - after realising that bowlers must be able to see what they are aiming at.
I’m somewhat surprised that that actually stopped them. Normally, the fact that you’d no longer be able to carry out the same function wouldn’t normally be considered a hindrance…
Instead they have told operators to fit photoelectric beams to lanes so that pin-setting machines will cut off automatically if anyone trespasses.

John Ashbridge, of The Ten-Pin Bowling Proprietors Association, said: 'I have been in this industry for 40 years and I have never known any member of the public injured by a bowling pinsetter. I have never heard of anybody going near the pins.'
But despite this, the HSE issued their orders regardless.
Mr Ashbridge said he had watched HSE inspectors examining a bowling centre and he found their attempts to detect possible dangers 'hilarious'.

He added: 'Some operators have now fitted photoelectric beams. They don't cause any problems - they don't stop the machines because nobody ever goes near the pins.'
They cost money, though. I expect the bowling lane operators found that a little less than hilarious…

Did something prompt this?

Oh, yes:
The HSE inquiry was begun after a technician was crushed to death in 2006 in Barking, East London, when a pin-setting machine was mistakenly left plugged in.
So, rather than issue instructions that leaving the machine plugged in could result in your technicians being folded, spindled and mutilated, they embarked on an epic two year quest to increase the overheads for bowling alleys all across the country…
Susie Squire, of the TaxPayers' Alliance, said: 'The HSE has overreacted to a one-off tragedy by wasting a fortune of taxpayers' money producing a pointless, naval-gazing report.'
Might as well criticise fish for swimming and birds for flying, Susie. It’s what they do

5 comments:

MTG said...

It was myopic to lampoon these safeguards, JuliaM. Specific instructions to humans will not render safe a machine with inherent dangers. Machines and moving parts must be guarded after a fashion that 'guards against unguarded moments'.

Think about it for a moment. The specific design leading to the fatality, was flawed.

BTW, the photo electric guard principle or other 'interlock' device was well established in law prior to the research stated to be in the region of £250,000.

Witterings from Witney said...

Perhaps bowlers can 'strike' a blow for freedom by just telling the HSE: 'balls'!

banned said...

What was that film where a US military officer got mangled to death in bowling alley machine ?
He was running away from the growing creepy thing that was taking over the landscape underground following some ghastly failed experiment.

ivan said...

This H&S stupidity is caused by people not being taught to think for themselves.

Many years ago there was the classic case where a butcher was instructed to install a safety barrier at the edge of a loading platform then the health department got involved and the butcher was told to remove it because the sides of meat might brush against it - the first inspector returned and insisted that the barrier be in place. Upshot - an up and down barrier.

H&S don't know what they are doing!

JuliaM said...

"It was myopic to lampoon these safeguards, JuliaM. Specific instructions to humans will not render safe a machine with inherent dangers."

Unplugging it might help.

You cannot legislate away human failings, no matter how much you try.

"Perhaps bowlers can 'strike' a blow for freedom by just telling the HSE: 'balls'!"

Well, yes. But that lays them open to legal action, I suspect.

"What was that film where a US military officer got mangled to death in bowling alley machine?"

Ooh! Don't know that one. But I note the use of an Approved Victim™

"This H&S stupidity is caused by people not being taught to think for themselves."

We just don't do personal responsibility in this country any more.