Tuesday, 4 May 2010

Brown: I Can Haz Sympathy Vote, Ladeez?

Well, Barbara Ellen certainly thinks so, anyway:
Did anyone else feel that Brown had been handed the third-place rosette before he even took to the podium? That, even before Brown screwed up with Gillian Duffy, everything he said and did, was to an accompaniment of abuse, insults and gloating – with Brown, the equivalent of a bull, determinedly trying to keep on its feet, despite a baying media crowd, and a back full of pollsters' spears. A "Get Gordon" bloodlust, which, in the end, was so obvious as to be foolish. After all, attack a guy often enough (for everything, for nothing) and it just may backfire and ignite the sympathy vote.
But, it appears, only with the distaff side:
I don't know a single person who's been asked their opinion for a poll. However, I do know quite a few people, many of them women, none of them ragingly partisan, who are quietly disgusted by the way Brown has been treated during this election.
Say what..? Did I miss something? Has he been pelted with eggs, or harangued by students?

Nope. After all, he has a security team to handle the latter. So what has he faced? Just questions from members of the public, whom he then sneers at and belittles when he thinks they can't hear him.

But apparently and unbelievably, for a certain type of female, this is unbearable:
"Even if it's time for him not to be prime minister, he seems like a decent man, and it's too much," said one woman. "Would Cameron or Clegg have done any better with his hand, I doubt it," sniffed another.
Oh, my giddy aunt!!
Always, at times such as these, the female vote ("the Mumsnet factor") is discussed as if it were a pink, fluffy silly thing – with women needing to be courted, flattered and directed, or – bubbleheads that we are – we may go mad and vote for someone because he is wearing a shiny tie. A reductionist view that is as untrue as it is insulting.
Reading the above, is it any wonder? You see a man who has been purely the architect of his own downfall and say 'Awww, they are SO MEAN!' like some bubble-headed California Valley girl...
In truth, most women are clever and pragmatic creatures, perfectly capable of assessing the core issues and thinking for themselves.
Well, not based on your own admissions in this article, Babs!

But it's a mistake to assume that she speaks for all women. She speaks for that (thankfully) rare species, Journalistus islingonii, and it's purely the yummy mummy, ladies-who-lunch demographic who are likely to be suckered into believing that Gordon deserves their vote because all the popular boys have been flushing his head down the toilet.

At least, I hope so....

Monday, 3 May 2010

Injustice

So, it wasn't enough that an attacker - who at first you said 'was not known to have had any mental health issues', but it appears you didn't look too hard before telling that to the press - is stabbed in self-defence and you arrest yet another person who has every right to defend their property and family.

It wasn't enough that you then held him for 12 hours - it took that long to check out the story? Seriously? - while his mother lay close to death in the hospital.

But now, you can't even let him have his property?
He can't go back to his house or get his clothes or his phone.
OK, it's a crime scene. Everyone knows that. We watch 'CSI' and 'The Bill'.

But you can't spare someone to take this lad - the innocent victim, not the perpetrator - back to his house to collect his belongings while ensuring he doesn't affect it?

Not for the sake of simple humanity, if the modern police 'service' lacks that (it clearly seems to, at times), but for some good PR..?

What, is there no target for it?

Right Target, Wrong Conclusions...

Patrick Basham & John Luik in ‘CiF’ try to outdo Deborah Ross in patronising rubbish:
It may sound anachronistic but working-class communities are experiencing an invasion of the public health toffs (PHTs). The primary object of the PHTs' ire is Average Joe, the stereotypical, overweight, working-class male who's a junk food addict and a betting shop regular, when he isn't impersonating a beer-swilling, chain-smoking couch potato – and they're also not fond of Average Jane's "addiction" to an artificial tan.
And those are uniquely ‘working class’ attributes are they..?

Nice start, chaps…
Joe and Jane are the subject of a PHT-designed regulatory experiment to improve their habits and preferences in order to improve the nation's health.

This assault on their culture is justified by the PHTs' acceptance of health paternalism, which provides the driving force behind the regulatory assault on inappropriate eating, drinking, smoking, gambling, and even tanning. For the PHTs, all of these activities are inappropriate because they pose unacceptable risks to healthy living.
You are quite correct, but to paint this as an attack on ‘working class culture’ is quite wrong.

These NuPuritans would be quite happy to turn their fire on the average middle class drinker/smoker/red meat eater too.
Health paternalism is committed to using the mechanisms of social engineering to ease the pleasures of working-class life gradually out of existence. Today, it's sufficient for PHTs to simply utter the dreaded U-word – "unhealthy" – and pleasures of whatever pedigree are doomed.
Well, at least until those scientists they’ve based their diktats on have a sudden change of heart, anyway…

And why just blame the PHTs - there's planty of 'ordinary' people who are more than capable of muscling in on this new game, as Dick Puddlecote points out with the saga of the chip-vending machines and the Netmums campaign.
… there's a growing sense in working-class communities of suffering endless condescension, a feeling that urbane Britain has written off their culture as aberrant or worse.
It’s not just in working class communities, chaps. Not by a long chalk…

What The Ambulance Service Has To Put Up With...

A drunk woman who dialled 999 for an ambulance outside a nightclub because she felt cold flew into a rage when hospital staff told her there was nothing wrong with her.
Nothing physical, anyway...

She then screamed racial insults at the staff and when police turned up to remove her, assaulted them too.
'In hindsight, it was wrong to do what I did, but I'm trying to forget about it. I just lashed out at the officer - I didn't mean it and it was only because of the drink.'
Let's hear it for that demon drink, which makes perfectly normal, sane individuals behave totally out of character. At least, so magistrates seem to think...
Adams, 46, escaped an immediate prison sentence after pleading guilty to charges of racially aggravated threatening behaviour and police assault, when she appeared before Manchester magistrates.

District Judge Paul Richardson branded her behaviour ‘appalling’ and gave her a two-month jail term, suspended for a year.
That'll teach her...

Oh, well, it's not like it was her fault (that evil, evil alcohol, you see, administered to her in secret without her consent), and she's really sorry, after all:
Martin Cunningham, defending, said his client had problems in her life and was ‘crying out for help.’

He said: 'She is very sorry for the police assault and has shown genuine contrition.'
And she's of previous good charact...

Oh:
The court heard how she had appeared in court for a similar incident in 2007 when she racially abused three Asian women at Manchester Royal Infirmary.

Sunder Katwala - Positive Discrimination Is The Answer!

Sunder Katwala is in favour of racist and discriminatory policies – but only so long as they favour ethnic minorities, naturally:
This could be the fifth general election since the black and Asian breakthrough in 1987 where the Lib Dems fail to elect any non-white MPs to parliament. As you report: "Only four minority candidates are fighting for the Lib Dems in the party's top 100 target seats." And yes, the Lib Dems have "recently begun a programme of mentoring young minorities"; but this won't make much difference without a far clearer understanding of the problem.
You do realise, Sunder, that it's not the party that elects those MPs to Parliament? It's the people? The voters?

Because you speak as if it were a foregone conclusion that if the party put up an MP, they would make it. Are you sure that's an assumption you want to make about this year's campaign?
Last year I gave evidence to the Speakers' conference on the underrepresentation of minorities. It is clear that Labour and Conservative progress has accelerated. Only four of New Labour's 183 new MPs in the landslide class of 1997 were non-white, but Labour selections now are more than five times as likely (over 10%) to see black and minority ethnic candidates win.
Note that, for Sunder, it's only 'black and minority ethnic' individuals who count as 'minorities'.
The Conservatives elected only one non-white MP in the 20th century. But David Cameron's efforts to change the face of the party have paid off: they are now selecting black or Asian candidates in more than 5% of all selections, with a higher rate in Conservative-held seats.
And it's proved immensely divisive, and until May 7th, no-one will know if it was a worthwhile gamble..
The Lib Dems have often boasted that they have more minority candidates than the major parties. But these have nearly always been in seats with large minority populations, where the party is weak. A diversity strategy far too heavily based on an "ethnic faces for ethnic voters" approach is bound to fail.
So we don't need ethnic minority candidates in heavily-ethnic areas, eh? Where do we need them, Sunder?
So the Lib Dems need to start selecting non-white candidates when they replace retiring MPs in Lib Dem seats like Winchester, York or St Ives.
Ah. OK. Well...
Lib Dem members are resistant to A-list style pressure from "above"; but they need to do something if they want a parliamentary party that looks anything like Britain.
Errr...

But a minute ago you were suggesting that we needed black and ethnic candidates in regions known mainly for their lack of them?

Now, you are concerned that we need a parliamentary party that 'looks like Britain' from candidates for areas that don't look anything like those areas?

Is anyone else confused by that 'reasoning'?

Modern British Bank Holiday Traditions...

There's the day out to the seaside or afternoon spent gardening (in the unlikely event it isn't raining), or the day spent indoors (if it is raining) just relaxing, or doing DIY.

And now there's the traditional 'break the planning laws while the council is on holiday' by those 'disadvantaged' travelling folk who never seem to want to do any actual travelling...
It wasn't quite how they imagined spending the Bank Holiday.

But residents of a village in the heart of England found themselves having to form a human barricade to prevent a band of gipsies from building an illegal settlement.
Well, if it was as wet there as it was here, might as well do the council's job for them...
In time-honoured fashion, the gipsies rolled on to the green-belt site on Friday evening in the hope of exploiting the long weekend.

They hoped to establish their camp while council officials were off work and powerless to stop them.
Not entirely sure why they bother. Councils seem powerless to stop them no matter what they do...
But they reckoned without the resolve of villagers and farmers who have camped day and night outside the eight-acre camp to prevent building materials being taken in.

On Sunday, the villagers told how they had given up their Bank Holiday weekends to preserve the tranquillity of the village of Meriden in the countryside close to Coventry in the West Midlands.
Unfortunately, the villagers will eventually have to go back to work. While the travellers...

Well, you get the picture.
...Solihull Council called officers in from their Bank Holiday to issue a stop notice, which prohibits further development for the next 28 days.

Despite that, the gipsies were yesterday seen putting up a shed on the land, in apparent contravention of the order.
And why not? Nothing ever happens to them. There are no consequences to breaching the planning laws for them.
Around 40 villagers remained in Meriden on Sunday, watched by police to ensure there was no breach of the peace.
So they can send police to ensure there's no breach of the peace, but not to ensure there's no breach of council planning laws?

I wish the villagers well, but I can only see one way this is going to end.

Libby Believes We Need The Smack Of Firm Government...

Libby Brooks weighs in on the EU smacking ban and how we should adopt it here immediately:
Earlier this week the Council of Europe – which monitors compliance with the European convention on human rights – berated Britain for having failed to introduce a smacking ban more than a decade after a ruling that the practice violated children's right to freedom from inhuman and degrading treatment. It's not the first time that Britain has been criticised over smacking – we are one of only five EU countries not to have introduced a ban – and it won't be the last time that such criticism has been blithely ignored.
How dare we? How very dare we ignore advice from our betters!
But, as the council steps up its campaign against physical punishment, it may well be that in coming months, defensive outrage is no longer an option.
How about ignoring them, then? Is that an option, Libby?
Any proposed variation of a smacking ban immediately ignites a toxic touchpaper, encompassing as it does our peculiarly British preoccupation with human rights, European diktat, homebound state interference, parental responsibility and children's place in society.
What, exactly, IS 'children's place in society', Libbty? Because it seems to me that it's shifted a little over the years.

No, scratch that. It's shifted a lot...
Thus it seems pointless to note that the UN Convention of the Rights of the Child, from which this all stems, was an international rather than a European document, which the British government was heavily involved in drafting.
Yes, well, you'll note that we are about as enthused over being told what to do by our government as we are over being told what to do by an unelected one...
That smacking is a stratospherically emotive issue, entrenched in generational and cultural expectations, is self-evident. But the contradictions in public attitude are manifest. While we weep over the death of Baby P, it is anathema to suggest that smacking might occupy a space – however limited – on the continuum of child abuse.
I'm not entirely sure that you can even begin that continuum with smacking as a starting point. Do you not realise how silly you sound?
…yet it would be entirely feasible to institute a smacking ban in this country that didn't penalise parents for reasonable interventions. Simply changing the "reasonable chastisement" defence against common assault to "reasonable restraint" would remove the covert approval of physical punishment while acknowledging the right to use force to stop a child darting into the path of a 4x4.
Ah. I see where Libby has gone wrong. She believes in the wisdom and guidance of lawyers to craft laws that punish the right target while avoiding harm to the unintended one.

She really should know better, shouldn't she?
…it's frequently contended that a ban would exist as a meaningless heartwarmer, given how impossible it is to police individual homes. And bans in general do invite a noxious response.
But it's not 'impossible to police individual homes'. It's just very, very expensive and time consuming.

And have no doubt, there will be people who are chomping at the bit like Grand National winners, waiting for the chance to try to do just that...
But what the naysayers avoid is the potential of a very public, governmental, condemnation of smacking.
Yes, indeed. We all listen to the government, right?
Only the Liberal Democrats have committed in their manifesto to incorporating the UN convention into British law, which is probably about as hopeless a daydream as proportional representation.
Or hearing the words 'Nick Clegg, Prime Minister' on May 7th...
But, in the meantime, we cannot rely on benign self-regulation by parents alone.
Let me rephrase that for you, Libby: 'Stupid proles can't be expected to make their own decisions...''
Smacking is assault, however you dress it up. It brings with it all the guilt, shame and assumptions of weakness and power that come with any attack on another human. The victim is in this case a smaller person, but still a person. Whether practically enforcible or otherwise, the message that such assaults will no longer tolerated is needed to prompt a complete cultural revision of attitudes to children that goes far beyond the Naughty Step.
We need a cultural revision of attitudes to children, all right. I agree with you there, Libby. I doubt we'd reach the same conclusion though...

Sunday, 2 May 2010

But Surely, They Can't Be Surprised..?

Christian campaigners said last night they were alarmed that the police seemed to be using legislation originally introduced to deal with violent and abusive rioters and football hooligans to curb free speech.
I wonder if, now this has hit the headlines, the police will be instructed to find a Muslim or Jewish preacher to make an example of, in ortder to 'balance the books'..?
Neil Addison, a barrister and expert on religious law, said: ‘People should be able to express their opinions freely as long as their conduct is reasonable. In fact, it is part of the duty of the police to protect free speech.’
Someone should really tell them that, shouldn't they?
Last night Cumbria police said there was no one available to comment on Mr Mcalpine’s case.
Funny, that...

Breathtakingly Patronising? – Check! It Must Be The ‘Indy’, Then…

Deborah Ross produces the most insulting, sneering article I’ve yet seen in the ‘Indy’. And that’s saying something.

She’s despatched to East London to go on the campaign trail with the BNP, just like...well, a lot of reporters. At this point, I’m beginning to wonder if the BNP doesn’t consist of just three men and a dog, and all the others in the entourage are journalists and documentary filmmakers…

I’m not alone in that thought either:
So, I'm off to spend the day with the British National Party which appals almost everyone I know – "Poor you"; "Say you're busy"; "Can't you pull a sickie?" – but I find I'm peculiarly thrilled and excited.
Eh..?
I find the BNP in Barking and Dagenham, which basically means going east on the District line until you fall off at the end.
Ummm, no, sweetie.

That would be Upminster, a good few stops further
As I tip up, an altercation is already taking place – oh, joy of joys – between a BNP man in a sandy-coloured suit and a fat, white tattooed fellow with a neck thicker than his head and a Staffordshire bull terrier snarling at his side. "You got a problem with my bird, looking over the fence," the tattooed man is shouting, while jabbing the sandy-suited man in the chest. "Next time you come over, I'll hit you with a shovel!"

My God, you don't get this at Blenheim! Hit him with the shovel! Quick, someone find him a shovel!
Any other strange and exotic native rituals these people should perform for you, Deborah?
But, disappointingly, the minders manage to talk the tattooed man down. What was that all about? I ask. "That," says one of the minders, "was because Richard Barnbrook [the sandy-suited man, a BNP councillor] looked over the other fellow's fence where his girlfriend was having a bonfire, and he got cross about it."
Oh, how quaint!
The minder is friendly and later updates me on where dog-fighting is at these days. "They use them Japanese akita dogs now. They can pick up a Staffie and it's gone." He also says: "I can't give you my real name, love, for security reasons, but it's Terry."
Gosh, it must be like starring in your very own episode of ‘Minder’ directed by Guy Ritchie, eh, Deborah?
The job, today, is to press the flesh and distribute flyers. The flyers come with the headline "New Labour Have Changed The Face of Barking & Dagenham" and juxtapose two photographs. One shows pretty, white young women in tea-dresses, lining a street on what appears to be VE Day, and has a "From this..." arrow on it. The other, meanwhile, has a "To this..." arrow on it, and shows three women in burkhas, one of whom is giving the finger. I confess I have never personally seen a woman in a burkha give the finger but, like I said, perhaps I've lived in some kind of bubble.
Well, we are beginning to rather get that impression, Deborah…

Now, this is all very amusing, but I suspect if she’d written in this vein about any other borough or area, it wouldn’t have graced the pages of such a politically-correct organ of the media as the ‘Indy’.

How about you?

How Is This Legal..?

A controversial campaign is urging people to give their general election vote to someone in Afghanistan, Bangladesh or Ghana.

Give Your Vote allows people from the three countries affected by UK policies to have a vote in the election.

Participants text their vote to a local number, which will be sent to people in the UK who have pledged to vote on their behalf.
Good grief, can you imagine a more pointless, self-absorbed political stunt?

What sort of person dreams up something like this? And what sort of person thinks it’s a good idea?
Fanny Rhodes-James, of Ballast Quay, Greenwich, has joined the campaign.
Ah. Right. Well, that answers my second question, at least.

Tremble before the political wisdom of Fanny:
She said: “I’m giving my vote as an act of solidarity with people around the world affected by my government.

“I want them to know people in the UK see them as equals. I’m not giving something away – I am making my vote more powerful.”
Errr…
The 23-year-old student added: “Its given me a fresh look a what the parties are offering to the world and not just to me personally.”
It’s a UK election, Fanny. Can you not manage to wrap your tiny mind around that?
Campaign co-ordinator James Sadri said: “Elections are a time when we should be debating the real political issues - like why do 20,000 children die every day because of hunger, when there is enough food for everyone?

“We live in an interconnected world, but because our politics is local, the issues which get debated and discussed are parochial.”
Because it’s an election to select your political representatives for your own country!

Good lord! It isn’t rocket science….

And as Bella Gerens' excellent post shows, if this is really something they feel strongly about, there are people far closer to home who would benefit from it.